We tend to think of a will as the clearest expression of a person’s final wishes: a document that speaks with certainty after someone is gone. But the law asks a deeper question before accepting those wishes: was the person actually capable of making them?
This idea is known as testamentary capacity, and it sits at the heart of many estate disputes. It’s not about whether a will is fair, kind, or even rational in the eyes of others. Instead, it’s about whether the person who made it understood what they were doing at the time.
To have capacity, the testator must understand a few important elements. They need to understand that they are making a will and the effects of their will. They should have a general sense of their assets, who might expect to benefit from their estate, and how their decisions affect those people, including the nature of any claims made by a person excluded under the will. In short, they must be able to connect their choices to real-world consequences.
What’s often misunderstood is what does not automatically destroy capacity. Poor physical or mental health does not, on its own, invalidate a will. A person can be depressed, taking medication, or living with significant illness and still meet the legal threshold. Courts have repeatedly emphasized that capacity is about cognition and understanding, not perfection or stability.
Still, even unusual or unpopular choices, including disinheriting family members, does not prove incapacity. People are allowed to make decisions others disagree with. The law protects that freedom, so long as the decision was made knowingly and intentionally.
Please reach out to us at info@mcdonaldsimon.com or call us at 519-273-2734.
Disclaimer: This blog should not be construed as legal advice. Each individual circumstance has nuances that need to be considered by a licensed legal professional and there is no one-size-fits- all answer in the law. If you require legal advice, please contact someone who is licensed with the Law Society of Ontario and is properly insured to provide legal services or practice law.
We use cookies to personalize content, provide social media features, and analyze our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our analytics partners. You can change your preferences at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy. Privacy Policy
